Most clients review their SEO agency by reading the monthly report. The problem is that the report is written by the agency. It shows what the agency chose to show, framed the way the agency chose to frame it. That does not make it dishonest, but it does make it an incomplete basis for deciding whether to renew, renegotiate or replace.
Our thesis: a useful agency audit verifies claims against evidence the client controls. That means checking access, the work actually delivered, the quality of that work, the links acquired in the client’s name, and whether the reporting connects to commercial outcomes. None of this requires accusing the agency of anything. It simply replaces trust with verification.
This checklist is organised in six areas. Each area lists what to ask for, what to check, and what tends to signal a problem.
Before you start: frame the review fairly
An agency audit goes better when everyone understands its purpose. Tell the agency that you are reviewing the engagement, what period you are covering, and what evidence you will need. Good agencies usually welcome this, because it gives them a chance to show work that does not fit neatly into a monthly report.
Also be honest about your side of the relationship. Agencies are often blocked by slow approvals, missing developer time, or briefs that changed mid-quarter. An audit that ignores client-side bottlenecks will reach the wrong conclusions.
Area 1: Access and ownership
Start here, because every other check depends on it.
- Does your company own the Google Search Console property, analytics property and tag manager container, with the agency added as a user rather than the other way round?
- Are SEO tool accounts, if paid for by you, registered to a company email address?
- Do you have copies of all content, briefs, technical audits and keyword research produced under the contract?
- If you ended the engagement tomorrow, would you lose access to anything?
Red flags: properties owned by the agency, content hosted on agency-controlled domains, or reports that cannot be reproduced because only the agency has the underlying data.
Area 2: Strategy and prioritisation
Ask the agency to explain the current strategy in plain language, then compare it with the work they have delivered.
- Is there a written strategy that names the business goals it supports?
- Are priorities linked to commercially important pages, products or services?
- Does the plan explain what is out of scope and why?
- Has the strategy been updated in response to results, or does it repeat the same tasks every quarter?
Red flags: strategies that consist of generic deliverables (“4 blog posts, 10 links, 1 technical audit per month”) with no connection to your commercial priorities.
Area 3: Deliverables and execution quality
This is where you check whether what was promised was delivered, and whether it was any good.
Verify volume
Compare the statement of work with a list of completed items. For each period, record what was contracted, what was delivered, and what was blocked, along with who caused the delay.
Verify quality
Pick a sample of deliverables and review them against simple standards:
- Content: Does it answer a real search need? Is it accurate? Does it duplicate or compete with existing pages?
- Technical recommendations: Are they specific, prioritised and explained in terms a developer can act on? Or are they unfiltered tool exports?
- On-page changes: Were title tags, internal links and page structures changed thoughtfully, and were the changes tracked?
- AI-assisted work: If the agency uses AI to draft content, briefs or reports, ask how the output is fact-checked and who signs it off. AI use is not a problem in itself; unreviewed AI text presented as expert work is.
Verify implementation
A recommendation that was never implemented has delivered no value, regardless of who is at fault. Track the share of recommendations that reached production and how long they took. The point is not to blame the agency for client-side delays, but to see whether the engagement as a whole is producing shipped work.
Area 4: Link acquisition
Links acquired on your behalf carry your brand and, in some cases, your risk. Ask for a complete list of links built during the engagement, including the URL, target page, anchor text, date and any cost.
Then check a sample:
- Is the linking site real, with genuine content and an audience, or does it exist mainly to sell links?
- Is the link relevant to your business and placed in useful context?
- Are paid placements marked appropriately? Google’s guidance on qualifying outbound links expects paid links to be marked, for example with
rel="sponsored". - Do anchor texts look natural, or are they repetitive exact-match commercial phrases?
Red flags: an agency that refuses to share the link list, links on networks of near-identical sites, or a cost per link that is reported but never itemised. For a deeper method, see our guide on evaluating link building spend.
Area 5: Reporting and measurement
Reports should help you make decisions. Check whether yours do.
- Does the report separate brand and non-brand search performance?
- Are results segmented by page type or commercial priority, or only shown as site-wide totals?
- Are conversions tracked, and are they connected to qualified leads or revenue rather than raw form submissions?
- Are rankings reported for terms that matter commercially, or for a curated list that happens to look good?
- When results decline, does the report explain why, or does it change the metrics?
- If the agency reports on visibility in AI-generated answers (GEO, Generative Engine Optimization), is the method documented and repeatable, or is it a handful of screenshots? No one can guarantee inclusion in AI answers, so treat such promises as a warning sign.
You can check much of this yourself. Google Search Console’s Performance report shows clicks, impressions and queries for your site. Compare its numbers with the figures in the agency report. Differences are not always a problem, since tools measure differently, but they should be explainable.
Area 6: Commercial terms and value
Finally, look at what you are paying for and how the contract is structured.
- What is the total cost, including the retainer, link budgets, content production and any tools billed separately?
- Is pricing tied to activity (hours, articles, links) or to defined outcomes, and does that match how you judge success?
- What are the notice period and exit terms?
- Who owns work in progress if the engagement ends?
There is no universal right price for SEO. The useful question is whether the money is concentrated where the evidence suggests it creates value.
Scoring the checklist
Use a simple, explainable scale for each area so the result can be discussed rather than argued about.
| Rating | Definition |
|---|---|
| Verified | Evidence was provided and supports the agency’s claims. |
| Partly verified | Some evidence exists, but there are gaps or inconsistencies to resolve. |
| Not verified | Evidence was requested but not provided, or contradicts the claims. |
| Not applicable | The area is outside the scope of this engagement. |
Hypothetical illustration, not a client case: a retailer finds that access and reporting are verified, deliverables are partly verified because a quarter of contracted content was never published, and link acquisition is not verified because the agency will only share a summary count. The next step is not to fire the agency. It is to request the link list, agree a plan for the unpublished content, and review again in a defined period.
Caveats: what this checklist can’t tell you
A checklist verifies inputs and process. It cannot by itself prove how much revenue an agency generated, because organic attribution is imperfect and many factors affect results.
Results depend on the client as much as the agency. Slow approvals, limited developer capacity or shifting priorities can block good work, and an audit should record these honestly.
Strong process does not guarantee future rankings or traffic. Search engines change, competitors act, and demand shifts. No reviewer can promise a specific outcome.
This is a marketing and operational review, not a legal or financial audit. Contract questions with legal implications should go to a qualified adviser.
Action checklist
- Confirm your company owns Search Console, analytics and tag manager properties.
- Collect all deliverables produced under the contract and store them on your systems.
- Ask for the written strategy and check that it names commercial priorities.
- Compare contracted deliverables with completed and implemented work, period by period.
- Review a sample of content and technical recommendations against basic quality standards.
- Request a full itemised link list with URLs, anchors, dates and costs.
- Reconcile agency-reported numbers with your own Search Console data.
- Check whether reported conversions connect to qualified leads or revenue.
- List total engagement cost, including items billed separately.
- Rate each area as verified, partly verified, not verified or not applicable.
Getting an independent view
Running this checklist internally is a good start. Some clients prefer an outside reviewer who has no stake in the outcome and can discuss findings with the agency directly. Our SEO team and agency audit covers each of these areas against your own evidence and explains how each conclusion was reached. If it would help, describe your situation and we will suggest a sensible scope.